JackSpirio's profile

Avatar
User
NB Posts : 134
Created :
Last visit :
User signature :
flag_curse_sm VG: icon_succes PoC: icon_succes IM: icon_succes
CS card_pick009: icon_succes, card_pick123: icon_succesicon_succes
VotE icon_succes SoM icon_succes

Card 180 (A0599)

64x64
Posted
#41
The rules are clear, I can’t understand having such an irrational resistance to understanding the rules.

"Return this." for the top card in a combined item...?

64x64
Posted
#42
jhaelen wrote:
JackSpirio wrote:
Yes and yes
I'd expect that second yes to be followed by a rules reference...

Oh, wait, coming from you that's of course unnecessary! ;-)

Yes, because I sleep on my rule book *facepalm*

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#43
Yes, we need rules, but we have them and they are enough to solve this problem

"Return this." for the top card in a combined item...?

64x64
Posted
#44
Yes and yes

Card 180 (A0599)

64x64
Posted - Edited
#45
Without such a rule, 2 pieces of rules text on the same card will either both apply or neither will apply.
Anything else is strictly against the rules.
Show me this rule
Answer you can’t.

Note: A rule that states "during the Results step" is text that applies at all times, not just during the results step.
Such text does exclude text that follows from being followed at other times, but does not exclude text before it from being followed during the results step.

Which text is normally applied during the Result step?
None
So why should a phrase which enables a sentence to apply at this point (like when drawn during the result step of an action) enable the whole card?
It enables everything which comes free it, but it does not include the text before it from being followed during the result step.

And yes, as card Text override rules, the rule it enable the Text, can be in the text itself.
There is nothing in the rules to prevent this.
It if there is show me this in the rules (of T7C, not of some other game)

Card 180 (A0599)

64x64
Posted
#46
Again, you make up your own rules and tell me that these are the rules.
They are not (see I can write bold too)
The card tells you what to do, this is what the rules tell you. Why do you have such a big problem with that?

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#47
You don’t need these errata as this is the only explanation that makes sense in the game.

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#48
Was that so hard?

Card 180 (A0599)

64x64
Posted
#49
Only your own rules break the card.
Where in the rules does it state that all text must always apply?

Card 180 (A0599)

64x64
Posted
#50
Just because you post the same thing over and over (with way too many lines) it doesn’t make it true.
Who gave you the right to universally define how games have to work?
Your logical fault is to think that things have to behave in only these two ways, which is completely wrong.
There is nothing that prevents a card from having only part active (the one that tells you that it is active).

Card 180 (A0599)

64x64
Posted
#51
Just because one person doesn’t understand the way the card is played, doesn’t mean it isn’t clear.
There are tons of players who don’t understand rules, but that isn’t always the rules fault.

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#52
It works perfectly for card 180
If you would do what it says, namely following the if revealed during the consequence step and applying it.

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#53
If you thought about that for a second you would realize that you've just created a paradoxon. If I have to read the text in order to find out if the text is to be read, then the text must always be read. Yo can't have it both ways. Either, the text is considered to be blank during the Result step of an action or not.
If the rules were amended to say that the text is to be ignored, then they'd have to introduce a new type of icon to be placed in the left border to signify that the card is supposed to be an exception with a text that isn't ignored.
It makes no sense to put an exception where it will always be ignored. That simply cannot work.
no it is not.
You are overcomplicating it.
It definitely can work as it uses a key phrase which tells you to do something when drawn under these circumstances.
The text is always there, it isn’t just gone because it can be ignored. This wouldn’t work as the cards are not changeable.
So you can always find this key phrase and do what it says, there is no problem with that.

Card sequence in the box?

64x64
Posted
#54
kriticizmas wrote:
I think, Jackspirio, this list is incomplete and based on id number instead of card number... It would be much easier if someone just checked their game and informed me. :]

Nope the list has everything in it, and you can even sort it for yourself (like for card numbers)

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#55
Yeah, it is pretty clear, he just likes to troll

"When there is a rockworm figure on your terrain card, you may not move to another terrain card."

64x64
Posted
#56
You only move to the space you enter, everything in between is ignored, as long as it is open terrain. As neither weather nor devourers tell you that the card changes it’s type, they are ignored while moving past them.

Card sequence in the box?

64x64
Posted
#57
There is a card list out there
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1UxFKydKJx7INjUp8BCJI5cwAvy_X4qiSFcz-ou5hERY

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#58
Card text when revealed during the result text isn’t active, unless it tells you so, which both of the cards you mention do.

Collector Edition vs Classic Edition

64x64
Posted
#59
Some of these cards are shown in the KS updates, but not all.
So it’s impossible right now to exactly tell you what they are.

When is card text active?

64x64
Posted
#60
The card tells you to do what it says on that case.
If it doesn’t specify that timing it is not active.
So I can’t discard a just drawn forewarned is forearmed, but the text on the flying roots card works.

Come on, you are just arguing to argue.